Official RankingsOhio

Top 10 Real Estate Agents in Youngstown, Ohio (April 2026)

The highest-ranked agents in Youngstown based on verified sales performance, client reviews, and market expertise.

$95,000

Median Home Price

Avg Days on Market

60068

Population

+3.8%

YoY Price Change

Dan Alvarez

Brokers Realty

5.0 (459)

Kelly Warren

Kelly Warren and Associates Real Estate Solutions

4.9 (289)

Tibitha Matheney

CENTURY 21 Lakeside Realty, Canfield

5.0 (137)

1,487

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Rollin Gosney

TG Real Estate

4.9 (229)

James Marzo

NextHome GO30 Realty

5.0 (83)

Joseph Merando

KLACIK REAL ESTATE

4.9 (62)

Bernadette Melago

Keller Williams Chervenic Realty

5.0 (30)

206

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Holly Ritchie

Keller Williams Chervenic Realty

5.0 (98)

3,869

Total Sales

Listings

Tyler Obradovich

Keller Williams Chervenic Realty

5.0 (94)

653

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Anthony Burrus

Brokers Realty

5.0 (155)

388

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Youngstown Real Estate Market

Youngstown offers some of the lowest home prices in the state, with a median around $95,000. The former steel city is working to reinvent itself through Youngstown State University, healthcare (Mercy Health), and advanced manufacturing. TJX's massive distribution center has added employment.

Homes average 40 days on market. The extremely low entry cost makes Youngstown one of Ohio's most attractive markets for cash-flow investors. A local agent helps buyers evaluate the most stable neighborhoods and identify properties with the best rental potential in this value market.