Finance
HELOC vs Home Equity Loan: How to Choose at Current Rates and Avoid a Payment Jump
A HELOC starts cheaper near 7.49%, but its payment can jump years later. Compare rates, $50,000 payment examples, closing costs, and current federal tax rules.
HELOC vs Home Equity Loan: How to Choose at Current Rates and Avoid a Payment Jump
The average HELOC rate was about 7.49% in early November, while the average 10-year home equity loan sat near 8.77%, according to Bankrate's national survey. On the surface, that makes the line of credit look like the easy winner. The lower rate is only part of the comparison, because one product can reset its rate and its payment years later and the other generally stays put.
Both products let you borrow against your home without touching your first mortgage. Both are second mortgages if you still owe on the first one, so you make that new payment on top of your existing one. The choice comes down to how you will spend the money, how quickly you can repay it, and how much payment risk your budget can absorb.
Rates, payments, closing costs, and taxes can each point in a different direction depending on your plan. For more on the financial side of owning a home, our homeowner and buyer guides cover related topics.
How Each One Works
A home equity loan pays you a lump sum at closing, and you start repaying it right away. Most come with a fixed rate and a set monthly payment, although the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau notes that some are adjustable. You know the payoff date on the day you sign.
A HELOC works more like a credit card secured by your house. You draw what you need up to a limit, pay interest only on what you have used, and regain available credit as you pay the balance down. HELOCs usually carry adjustable rates, and many lenders tie them to the prime rate.
The Two Phases of a HELOC
Most HELOCs start with a draw period of up to about 10 years, followed by a repayment period that often runs 10 to 20 years. During the draw period, many lenders require interest-only payments. Once repayment starts, your payment covers principal and interest, and you can no longer borrow.
That switch is where borrowers get caught. The monthly bill can rise by a large amount in a single month, and it arrives years after you opened the account.
The Simpler Structure of a Home Equity Loan
Common terms include 5, 10, and 15 years. Every payment reduces principal from the start, so the balance falls on a known schedule.
You give up flexibility in exchange. Interest starts on the full amount on day one, even if your contractor will not need most of it for six months, and borrowing more means applying for a new loan.
Where Rates Stand Right Now
Bankrate's survey of the 10 largest banks and thrifts in 10 large US markets showed these approximate averages as of November 4. It assumes a $30,000 balance, a 700 credit score, and a combined loan-to-value ratio of 80%.
| Product | Average rate | Range in the survey |
|---|---|---|
| HELOC | About 7.49% | 3.99% to 11.95% |
| 5-year home equity loan | About 8.66% | 6.00% to 10.49% |
| 10-year home equity loan | About 8.77% | 6.25% to 10.54% |
| 15-year home equity loan | About 8.76% | 7.24% to 10.75% |
Rates have been climbing. Bankrate's HELOC average was about 7.36% on October 21 and rose to about 7.49% two weeks later. Its survey at that time described home equity loan rates as the highest since May 2024.
Those averages come from large banks, and your quote could look quite different. LendingTree reported an average near 6.65% among its partner lenders for home equity loans, which is a different sample with different assumptions. Get quotes from a bank, a credit union, and an online lender, and ask whether any low HELOC rate is a temporary introductory offer.
The Same $50,000 Under Each Option
Take a $50,000 balance at the survey averages. These are rough calculations and not lender quotes.
A 10-year home equity loan at 8.77% costs about $627 a month, with about $25,260 in total interest. The payment holds steady for the full term, assuming a fixed rate.
A HELOC at 7.49% costs about $312 a month while you pay interest only. If the rate holds and you pay the minimum for 10 years, your balance is still $50,000 when repayment starts, and the payment moves to about $402 on a 20-year schedule. Total interest over those 30 years comes to about $84,050.
Discipline changes that picture. Pay the HELOC down over 10 years at the same 7.49% rate and you spend about $593 a month and about $21,190 in interest, which beats the fixed loan. A rate rise of one point would add about $42 a month to the interest-only payment on that balance, and two points would add about $83.
A HELOC rewards people who will pay it off early. A borrower who will only ever make the minimum payment is usually better off with the fixed loan, even at the higher rate.
What You Can Borrow and What It Costs to Open
Lenders commonly limit you to about 80% combined loan-to-value, and some go higher. On a $500,000 home with a $300,000 mortgage, 80% works out to $400,000 in total debt, leaving roughly $100,000 of borrowing room. Your credit score, income, and debts will also affect the amount.
Closing costs typically run about 2% to 5% of the loan amount, or about $1,000 to $2,500 on $50,000. Some HELOC lenders waive those costs, then charge them back if you close the line early. Ask about annual fees, inactivity fees, and early closure fees too, because a "no closing cost" offer can recover its money elsewhere.
Federal rules also give you a cooling-off period on your main home. You generally have until midnight of the third business day after closing to cancel, but this protection does not cover a second home.
How the Tax Rule Works
Interest on either product is deductible only if you use the money to buy, build, or substantially improve the home that secures the debt. IRS Publication 936 spells out that test for 2025 returns, and tax-professional summaries of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act say the law made these limits permanent. Using the money for credit cards, a car, or tuition does not qualify.
Your total qualifying mortgage debt is capped at $750,000, or $375,000 if married filing separately, and that limit counts your first mortgage and the home equity debt together. Older debt from before December 16, 2017 can fall under a $1 million limit. You also have to itemize, so the deduction gives nothing to a household taking the standard deduction.
Keep contractor invoices and receipts that show where the borrowed money went, and ask a tax professional how these rules apply to your return. Do not choose between these products based on a deduction you have not confirmed you can claim.
Which One Fits Your Situation
The right answer usually follows from how the money will go out the door. A few common cases:
- A remodel paid in stages over a year favors a HELOC, because you pay interest only on what you have drawn.
- A single known cost, such as a new roof or a fixed contract, favors a home equity loan, because you need all the money at once.
- Paying off high-interest debt usually favors a home equity loan, because the fixed payoff date forces the balance to zero.
- A backup fund favors a HELOC, because an untouched line generally costs little, though a lender may freeze it when you need it most.
A tight monthly budget points toward the home equity loan, since a rising HELOC payment has nowhere to go. A planned sale in the next few years points toward whichever option has the lowest upfront cost, because either balance gets paid off from your sale proceeds.
Debt consolidation deserves extra care. Moving credit card balances onto your house can lower the rate, but it turns unsecured debt into debt secured by your home. Running the cards back up afterward leaves you worse off than where you started.
Risks That Apply to Both
Your home is the collateral on both products. Falling behind can lead to foreclosure, which is a much heavier consequence than a late credit card payment.
Home values also matter. Lenders can reduce or freeze a HELOC in some cases, such as when a home's value drops or your finances change, so a line should not be your only safety net. Borrowing close to your limit also leaves little room if you need to sell during a soft market, since closing costs and both loan balances come out of the proceeds.
HELOC and Home Equity Loan Questions
Is a HELOC or home equity loan cheaper right now?
On Bankrate's early November averages, the HELOC starts lower at about 7.49% against about 8.77% for a 10-year loan. That gap of roughly 1.3 points can close if rates rise, since most HELOCs adjust over time. Compare total interest under your own repayment plan and not only the starting rate.
Can I have both at the same time?
Some lenders allow it if your combined debt stays within their limit, often about 80% of the home's value. On a $500,000 home, that means all your mortgage debt together would generally stay at or below $400,000. Each account brings its own payment and fees.
Is home equity interest tax deductible this year?
It can be, but only when the money goes toward buying, building, or substantially improving the home that secures the loan, and only if you itemize. The $750,000 debt cap still applies to your combined qualifying debt. A tax professional can confirm how this applies to you.
How long does a HELOC draw period last?
Up to about 10 years is common, although some plans run as short as 3 to 5 years. Check your agreement for the exact end date and the payment that follows it. A 20-year repayment schedule on $50,000 at 7.49% would run about $402 a month.