Rent vs Buy
← All Posts

Finance

Rent vs Buy: How to Run the Numbers for Your Market and Your Timeline

Rent vs buy comes down to price-to-rent ratio, breakeven time, and transaction costs. Run the math with a worked example at today's roughly 7.2% mortgage rates.

·November 13, 2026·9 min read

Rent vs Buy: How to Run the Numbers for Your Market and Your Timeline

In early November, Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate at about 7.18%, up from about 6.22% a year earlier. That single number shifted the math for millions of households. On a $320,000 loan, it adds roughly $200 to the monthly principal and interest payment compared with last year's rate.

The rent vs buy decision still is not one you can settle with a rule of thumb, or a line about throwing money away on rent. Renters and owners both pay costs they never get back, and the question is which pile is smaller over the time you plan to stay. Below is a way to run the numbers yourself, including a worked example you can swap your own figures into.

Start With the Price-to-Rent Ratio

Divide a home's price by the annual rent on a comparable home, and you have the fastest screening test in real estate. A $400,000 house that would rent for $2,300 a month has an annual rent of $27,600, so its price-to-rent ratio is about 14.5. A common rule of thumb says a ratio under 15 tends to favor buying, and anything over about 20 or 21 tends to favor renting.

The comparison only works if the two homes are alike. A three-bedroom house with a yard should be measured against a similar house for rent, not a one-bedroom apartment. Pull three or four rental listings in the same neighborhood and use the middle number.

This ratio is a screen rather than an answer. It ignores your interest rate, taxes, how long you will stay, and how much your down payment could earn somewhere else. So a low number tells you the full math is worth doing, while a high one warns you that buying needs a longer horizon or faster price growth to work.

A Worked Example With Real Math

Say you are choosing between buying that $400,000 house and renting a comparable one for $2,300 a month. You put 20% down, or $80,000, and pay about 3% in closing costs, or $12,000. A 30-year loan on the remaining $320,000 at 7.2% has a monthly principal and interest payment of about $2,172.

Here is how the first month compares, using rough assumptions for taxes, insurance, and upkeep that vary widely by location:

Monthly cost, first yearBuyingRenting
Principal and interest$2,172None
Property tax at about 1.1%$367None
Homeowners or renters insurance$175$20
Maintenance at about 1% a year$333None
RentNone$2,300
Total$3,047$2,320

The owner pays about $727 more per month at the start, and only part of that builds wealth. In the first month, about $1,920 of the mortgage payment goes to interest and about $252 goes to principal. That split improves slowly, and it is why owning tends to look worse in the early years.

Now suppose the home appreciates 3% a year, rent climbs 3% a year, and the renter invests the $92,000 upfront money plus the monthly savings at a 5% annual return. If the owner sells and pays 7% in selling costs, the renter stays ahead for about 11 years, and buying pulls ahead around year 12. Treat these as assumptions rather than forecasts, since the point of the exercise is to see how much the answer moves when they change.

How Long Until Buying Breaks Even

Change one input in that example, and the breakeven shifts dramatically. With the same home priced against a $2,800 rent, buying wins in about 5 years. With a 6% mortgage rate instead of 7.2%, it takes about 7 years, and 4% annual appreciation also brings it to around 7.

The numbers can also move the other way. At a $1,900 rent, or with appreciation of just 1.5% a year, the owner in this model does not catch up within 20 years. That spread is the most useful lesson here: the same house can be a great purchase or a poor one depending on local rent and price growth.

Your likely time in the home is the piece you control. If there is a real chance of moving in three or four years for work or a change at home, renting usually protects you from a costly round trip. Plan around a horizon you would bet on, and use a shorter one if you are unsure.

Transaction Costs Are the Hidden Hurdle

Buyers commonly pay about 2% to 5% of the purchase price at closing for lender fees, title, escrow, and prepaid items. Sellers often pay around 6% to 10% when commissions, transfer taxes, and concessions are included, while closing costs alone tend to be closer to 1% to 3%. Your rates may differ, and commissions are negotiable.

Add those together, and a round trip can eat roughly 10% of a home's value. On a $400,000 home, that is around $40,000 to clear before you are truly ahead. At 3% appreciation it can take more than three years of price growth just to cover it, which explains why short stays so often favor renting.

Renting has its own friction, though smaller: moving costs, application fees, and rent increases you do not control. Those costs can add up if a landlord sells or raises the rent sharply, so count them honestly. Some households value the stability of a fixed payment enough to accept a slower financial payoff, and that is a fair personal choice.

What Your Down Payment Could Earn Instead

The $80,000 down payment in the example does not disappear, but it stops earning market returns. At 5%, that money and the closing costs would generate about $4,600 in the first year. That is real money, and it belongs in the comparison even though nobody sends you a bill for it.

Compare that with what the money earns inside the house, which is a mix of appreciation and avoided rent. Leverage cuts both ways here. A 3% rise on a $400,000 home adds $12,000 of value on $80,000 down, while a 3% decline takes away the same amount.

The comparison only holds if the renter invests the difference. If those savings tend to get spent, a mortgage works as a forced savings plan, and the math may tilt back toward buying. Be honest about your habits when you fill in this row, and consider what happens if your investments fall or you need the cash for an emergency.

Tax Treatment for Owners and Renters

Many buyers overestimate the mortgage interest deduction. It only helps if you itemize, and the 2026 standard deduction is $32,200 for married couples filing jointly and $16,100 for single filers. In the example, roughly $23,000 of first-year interest plus about $4,400 of property tax falls short of that joint threshold, so a married couple with no other deductions would get no added benefit from them.

Federal law now permanently limits the interest deduction to the first $750,000 of acquisition debt for most new mortgages. The state and local tax deduction cap rose to about $40,400 for 2026, with a phase-down for higher incomes. Buyers in high-tax states with larger loans are the most likely to see real value here.

Sale profits get favorable treatment. Owners who meet the ownership and use tests, generally two of the last five years, can usually exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 for married couples filing jointly. Renters get no comparable federal break on rent, though some states offer a credit, and a tax professional can tell you what applies to your situation.

How the Answer Changes by Market

High-price coastal markets often show ratios well above 20, because prices have climbed much faster than rents. In those places, buying usually needs a long stay or strong appreciation to pay off, and renting while investing the difference can look better on paper. Many Midwest and Southern metros show ratios closer to the mid-teens, where a buyer can break even much sooner.

Local costs can matter as much as the ratio. Property taxes range from well under 1% to more than 2% of value depending on the state, which on a $400,000 home is a swing of several hundred dollars a month. Insurance can swing just as hard in hurricane and wildfire zones, so get an actual quote early.

Supply also shapes the outlook. A metro adding many new apartments may see flat rents, which favors renters, while a place with little land and steady job growth may see higher prices over time. An experienced local agent can pull real comps, and our real estate market and finance guides offer more context as you narrow your options.

Run your final version with real quotes before you decide. A lender can give you an actual rate and payment, and a financial adviser can test the plan against your savings, debts, and other goals.

Rent vs Buy Questions Readers Ask

Should I wait for mortgage rates to fall before buying?

Waiting only helps if prices and rents do not rise faster than the payment falls. Rates have moved about a full point in the past year alone, so timing them is hard. If you buy now, you may be able to refinance later if rates drop, though that typically costs 2% to 5% of the loan.

Does a smaller down payment change the answer?

Yes. Putting 5% down frees cash for other uses, but it raises your loan balance and usually adds mortgage insurance until you reach about 20% equity. On a $400,000 home, that could add around $100 to $300 per month, so run both versions.

Is renting forever a mistake?

No, as long as you are saving and investing the difference. A renter who consistently invests for 30 years can build substantial wealth without home equity. The risk is rent growth in retirement, so plan for housing costs that keep rising.