Official RankingsPennsylvania

Top 10 Real Estate Agents in New Castle, Pennsylvania (April 2026)

The highest-ranked agents in New Castle based on verified sales performance, client reviews, and market expertise.

$92,300

Median Home Price

Avg Days on Market

21800

Population

+4.2%

YoY Price Change

Patrick Russell

Berkshire Hathaway Home Service The Preferred Realty

4.9 (58)

Jennifer reilly

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices - The Preferred Realty

4.9 (96)

593

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

AnnaMarie DeFrank

Compass RE

4.8 (20)

Realty ONE Group Ultimate

4.5 (60)

1,317

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Caren Foy

Keller Williams Realty Pittsburgh South

5.0 (12)

996

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Richard Maiella

HOWARD HANNA REAL ESTATE SERVICES

4.9 (45)

1,425

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Katelyn Dominelli

Keller Williams Steel City

5.0 (30)

Maureen Chiafullo-Haid

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices

5.0 (13)

140

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Eleni Papandreas Chmura

Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

5.0 (14)

162

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Barb Forsythe

Your Home Town Realty LLC

5.0 (36)

New Castle presents one of western Pennsylvania's most affordable housing markets, with median prices that enable entry-level buyers to achieve homeownership with minimal financial strain. The city's economy has diversified from its industrial roots, with healthcare and retail now driving employment.

Historic homes downtown and in the North Hill neighborhood offer architectural character at bargain prices, while surrounding areas of Lawrence County provide larger lots and newer construction. New Castle's strategic position between Pittsburgh and Youngstown gives it commuter appeal for buyers prioritizing affordability above all else.