Official RankingsNew York

Top 10 Real Estate Agents in Jamestown, New York (April 2026)

The highest-ranked agents in Jamestown based on verified sales performance, client reviews, and market expertise.

$100,000

Median Home Price

Avg Days on Market

29578

Population

+3.8%

YoY Price Change

Heather canaley

ERA Team VP

5.0 (90)

Real Estate Advantage

5.0 (122)

Eric Anderson - NY Licensed R.E. Broker

Premier listings Real Estate

5.0 (126)

1,326

Total Sales

Years Exp

Listings

Jason Genberg - NY Licensed Assoc. R.E. Broker

Property Match USA

5.0 (70)

255

Total Sales

Listings

Taylor Bennett - NY Licensed R.E. Salesperson

Keller Williams Realty

5.0 (46)

Nicole Genberg - NY Licensed R.E. Salesperson

PropertyMatch USA

4.9 (62)

Laura Ferraro - NY Licensed R.E. Salesperson

Premier Listings Real Estate

5.0 (50)

Jerod Zahn - NY Licensed R.E. Salesperson

ERA Team VP

5.0 (27)

Richard and Julia McMahon

Real Estate Advantage

5.0 (128)

Tiffany Borst

PropertyMatch USA

4.7 (54)

Jamestown Real Estate Market

Jamestown sits on Chautauqua Lake in western New York, with a median home price around $100,000 making it one of the state's most affordable markets. The city's connection to Lucille Ball through the National Comedy Center has boosted tourism, while Chautauqua Institution draws summer visitors.

Homes average 45 days on market. Lakefront properties on Chautauqua Lake command significant premiums over in-city homes. Investors find excellent cash-flow potential at these low entry prices. A local agent helps buyers evaluate both the urban market and the lakeside seasonal home opportunities.