---
canonical: https://www.top10reagents.com/ny/jamestown
---

# Top Real Estate Agents in Jamestown, New York

> Find top Jamestown NY real estate agents. Explore ultra-affordable homes near Chautauqua Lake in western New York.

**Agents Ranked:** 10 | **State:** New York

---

## Top 10 Agents

### #1 Heather canaley
- **Brokerage:** ERA Team VP
- **Total Sales:** 772
- **Avg Rating:** 5
- **Years Experience:** 11
- **Listings:** 10

### #2 Real Estate Advantage
- **Brokerage:** Real Estate Advantage
- **Total Sales:** 1482
- **Avg Rating:** 5
- **Years Experience:** N/A
- **Listings:** 18

### #3 Eric Anderson - NY Licensed R.E. Broker
- **Brokerage:** Premier listings Real Estate
- **Total Sales:** 1326
- **Avg Rating:** 5
- **Years Experience:** 20
- **Listings:** 22

### #4 Jason Genberg - NY Licensed Assoc. R.E. Broker
- **Brokerage:** Property Match USA
- **Total Sales:** 255
- **Avg Rating:** 5
- **Years Experience:** N/A
- **Listings:** 0

### #5 Taylor Bennett - NY Licensed R.E. Salesperson
- **Brokerage:** Keller Williams Realty
- **Total Sales:** 821
- **Avg Rating:** 5
- **Years Experience:** 13
- **Listings:** 14

### #6 Nicole Genberg - NY Licensed R.E. Salesperson
- **Brokerage:** PropertyMatch USA
- **Total Sales:** 508
- **Avg Rating:** 4.9
- **Years Experience:** 15
- **Listings:** 5

### #7 Laura Ferraro - NY Licensed R.E. Salesperson
- **Brokerage:** eXp Realty LLC Team Premier Listings
- **Total Sales:** 343
- **Avg Rating:** 5
- **Years Experience:** 22
- **Listings:** 0

### #8 Jerod Zahn - NY Licensed R.E. Salesperson
- **Brokerage:** ERA Team VP 
- **Total Sales:** 658
- **Avg Rating:** 5
- **Years Experience:** 29
- **Listings:** 3

### #9 Richard and Julia McMahon
- **Brokerage:** Real Estate Advantage 
- **Total Sales:** 778
- **Avg Rating:** 5
- **Years Experience:** 34
- **Listings:** 16

### #10 Tiffany Borst
- **Brokerage:** PropertyMatch USA
- **Total Sales:** 568
- **Avg Rating:** 4.7
- **Years Experience:** 15
- **Listings:** 12

---

## Frequently Asked Questions — Jamestown Real Estate

### What is the average home price in Jamestown, New York?

The median home price in Jamestown is $100,000. Prices vary by neighborhood and property type — a local real estate agent can give you a current comparative market analysis for the specific area and home size you're targeting.

### How long does it take to sell a home in Jamestown?

Homes in Jamestown spend an average of 45 days on the market. Well-priced, well-presented homes in desirable neighborhoods often sell faster, while properties that need work or are priced above market may take longer.

### How do I find the best real estate agent in Jamestown, New York?

Look for agents with documented sales history, strong local reviews, and direct experience in Jamestown's neighborhoods. Top10REAgents ranks the highest-performing agents in Jamestown based on documented sales volume, client ratings, and market expertise — all agents listed here meet a minimum 4.5-star rating threshold.

### Do I need a buyer's agent to purchase a home in Jamestown?

In New York, buyers are not legally required to use an agent, but working with one is strongly recommended. A local buyer's agent in Jamestown will have access to off-market listings, negotiate on your behalf, and guide you through inspection, financing, and closing — at no direct cost to you (seller typically covers commissions).

### How much does a real estate agent cost in Jamestown?

In New York, total agent commission is typically 4–6% of the sale price, split between the buyer's and seller's agents. Since the NAR settlement in 2024, commission structures have become more flexible — ask any listed agent for a clear breakdown of their fees before signing.

### What questions should I ask a real estate agent in Jamestown?

Ask about their recent sales in Jamestown specifically, how many transactions they've closed in the last 12 months, how they'll market your home (or source listings for buyers), their communication style, and whether they work solo or with a team. A strong local agent will have direct answers for all of these.

### What explains Jamestown NY extremely low median home prices?

Jamestown is a former furniture and manufacturing center in Chautauqua County that experienced decades of industrial decline and population loss, creating abundant housing supply at rock-bottom prices. It is one of a handful of small New York cities where buyers can still find habitable single-family homes for under $60,000, making it a magnet for cashflow investors and budget-conscious first-time buyers.

### Is Jamestown proximity to Lake Erie and Chautauqua Lake a factor in real estate demand?

Absolutely — properties on or near Chautauqua Lake, just minutes from Jamestown, command prices many multiples above the city baseline and operate as a distinct luxury lakefront market. The broader Chautauqua County area is also a popular second-home market for buyers from Pittsburgh, Cleveland, and Buffalo, which adds a vacation-home layer to the region.

### What is the role of the National Comedy Center in Jamestown real estate?

The National Comedy Center, opened in 2018 as a tribute to native Lucille Ball, has been part of a broader downtown revitalization effort that has drawn new restaurants, visitors, and attention to Jamestown. While not yet dramatically moving residential prices, it has improved the city image and contributed to incremental neighborhood stabilization near downtown.

### Are there investment opportunities in Jamestown for out-of-area buyers?

Jamestown is well-established on the radar of out-of-state investors seeking high-yield residential rentals because gross rent multiples are far superior to most other markets. Buyers should be prepared for active property management or a strong local property manager relationship, as the tenant pool and maintenance demands require hands-on oversight to maximize returns.

---

*Source: https://www.top10reagents.com/ny/jamestown*